Enterprise Risk Management in the Banking IndustryDaxen Stewart
February 7, 2012 — 1,376 views
After the financial collapse in 2008 that was marked by the demise of some of the oldest financial firms in the banking industry, enterprise risk management has become a regulatory concern as well as a business concern. Assuring that the institutions which form the backbone of the country's economic infrastructure are observing proper operation risk management practices is seen as benefiting all citizens, not just customers and shareholders. Regulatory form, which has been the subject of press coverage and congressional inquiry, will certainly take a central role in the upcoming presidential race. As such, understanding critical factors is an important part of being well informed.
Enterprise risk management refers to practices that are specifically designed to protect the very existence of the business, or enterprise, for which they are implemented. Within the banking industry, this can refer to an ever-changing group of risks. In recent years, these have focused on practices that protect against allowing a financial institution from becoming over-leveraged.
The meltdown in 2008 was largely precipitated by banks over-extending credit which in turn impacted the real estate market as well as the very viability of the institutions which had issued that credit. When defaults began to occur, a cascading effect took place and the entire economy was put in jeopardy. Operational risk management refers to managing those risks which are directly related to the operation of the business in question. In most cases, these risks represent enterprise risks as well, but the overlap between the two terms is not absolute.
Over the past several years, there have been a variety of developments that have had a significant impact on the market. The Dodd-Frank legislation, changes in margin requirements and alteration to reserve requirements are just a few of the regulatory changes that have been enacted and targeted at forcing sound enterprise risk management practices. The Federal Reserve, the Securities and Exchange Commission and others have all worked towards reforming Wall Street for the overall protection of the economy and tax payers in general.
An example of one of the operational risk management changes that has been imposed on the banking industry is the practice of regularly conducting stress tests to be sure that the assets of any financial institution that is deemed "too large to fail" are not over-encumbered. The specifics of each test are highly complex, but the purpose of the exercise is to assure regulators that the institution in question can manage its exposure. Practices like requiring any lender to keep a certain percentage of the loans they make on their own balance sheet also help to protect the long-term viability of the institution by trying to force good judgement.
The Big Picture
The issue that is likely to be debated going into the presidential race is the cost of imposing operational risk management practices on free enterprise. While it is hard to argue that protecting the economy as a whole is in the best interest of all citizens, any time the free market is restricted, there is a cost. Some argue that the cost is too high and has unseen consequences that cannot be risked, while others defend these practices as a balance to natural greed. In any event, the discussion is an important one that will have a deep impact on the global economy for the foreseeable future.